MilikMilik

How Apple's New Siri AI Stacks Up Against ChatGPT and Gemini on Mac

How Apple's New Siri AI Stacks Up Against ChatGPT and Gemini on Mac
Minat|High-Quality Software

What Siri AI on macOS 27 Is – and How It Now Works

Siri AI on macOS is Apple’s new conversational assistant built into macOS 27, designed to answer natural-language questions, control your Mac, and search your files while using on-device AI processing for better privacy and speed. Available through a waitlist as a developer beta on supported Macs running macOS 27 Golden Gate, the new Siri can be triggered by voice, a Dock app, keyboard shortcuts, or contextual “Ask Siri” menus. In day-to-day use it behaves more like an efficient aide than a chat companion: instead of small talk, it tends to deliver short, direct answers and links. According to ZDNET’s hands-on testing, this early version is “more useful than old Siri but still makes mistakes,” especially with accuracy and conversation flow, so Apple Intelligence features are promising but not yet on the level of mature chatbot rivals.

ChatGPT vs Gemini vs Siri AI: General Knowledge and Advice

In broad information tasks, Siri AI macOS performance now feels closer to ChatGPT and Gemini, but not quite equal. When asked why the Roman Empire fell, Siri gave a concise spoken explanation, clear bullet points, and clickable sources, which is similar in depth to what you might see from leading chatbots. Where it trails is initiative and synthesis. For a shopping-style query about which laptop to buy on a set budget with specific preferences, Siri’s first response was a list of links and social posts instead of its own recommendation. Only after a follow-up prompt did it summarize the material and offer an opinion. In contrast, ChatGPT and Gemini typically start with a structured answer and optional references. This shows how consumer expectations, shaped by ChatGPT vs Gemini comparisons, now demand strong default reasoning rather than link curation.

On-Device AI Processing, Privacy, and Apple’s Core AI Stack

One of Siri AI’s key advantages on macOS 27 is on-device AI processing. Apple Intelligence features rely on a Core AI framework and Apple’s Foundation Models, tuned to run efficiently on supported chips so more of your data stays on your Mac. That means tasks like searching local files, analyzing personal photos, or pulling calendar details do not need to send everything to remote servers, which is a strong privacy story compared to cloud‑first assistants. This stack is backed by the MLX framework, Apple’s machine-learning toolkit for native performance optimization on Apple silicon. While ChatGPT and Gemini can feel smarter in free-form reasoning, they typically depend on constant network access and shared back-end models. Siri’s design pushes toward a more private, integrated assistant, even if its reasoning and flexibility still need to catch up to cloud rivals.

How Apple's New Siri AI Stacks Up Against ChatGPT and Gemini on Mac

macOS 27 Siri in Real Use: Files, Photos, and Visual Tasks

In practical Mac workflows, the new Siri AI is a mixed story. It now has deeper hooks into macOS 27 Siri controls, so you can search with natural language via the Command shortcut, summon the Siri AI app, or right-click to “Ask Siri” about a window or item. It can find appointments, toggle settings, and search your Photos library, but reliability is uneven. When asked to locate all photos of a specific statue, Siri surfaced only three shots even though six matched in the library, and similar partial results occurred with other photo queries. Visual understanding also lags behind what users may expect from ChatGPT or Gemini: when given paintings to identify, Siri misnamed works and artists in multiple attempts before finally recognizing a well-known Van Gogh image. These gaps highlight how far Apple still needs to go on local perception and file intelligence.

Conversation Flow and the Road Ahead for Siri AI on Mac

Siri AI can hold basic back-and-forth chats, but its conversation flow still feels stiffer than ChatGPT or Gemini. In a test about a picky cat’s eating habits, Siri offered sensible guidance and followed up by asking whether the cat ate wet or dry food, then refined its advice. However, the interface often closed the thread instead of keeping a natural, continuous chat space open, forcing the user to restart context. ZDNET notes that Apple “needs to improve accuracy and conversation flow,” and current beta behavior supports that assessment. With macOS 27 Golden Gate iterating through developer betas, there is time for polish before public release. For now, Siri AI macOS is a promising, privacy-first assistant whose Apple Intelligence features and on-device AI processing set a solid foundation, but consumer benchmarks defined by ChatGPT vs Gemini remain the standard it still has to meet.

Milik earns a commission when you shop through our links, at no extra cost to you. Editorial content is independently selected by our team.

You May Also Like

Comments
Katakan sesuatu...
Belum ada komen lagi. Jadi yang pertama berkongsi pendapat!